Case studies

Public sector

Payroll Fraud

Biometric verification prevents unauthorized overtime approvals and identifies anyone attempting to bypass the approval process.

Customer
Public School District
overtime fraud after rollout
Zero
The approval now carries the human who gave it, not the account it was given under.

The situation

The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners defines payroll fraud as “any scheme in which an employee causes an employer to issue a payment by making false claims for compensation”. Every organization that pays employees can be a victim.

This case concerns itself mainly with fraudulent overtime claims, though employees find many other ways to claim more pay than they are owed: buddy punching, ghost workers, double transactions. It usually occurs in systems without true identity management, where dishonesty hides behind a password. Since passwords can be shared, guessed or stolen, it is difficult to assign blame for fraud committed with one.

The institution faced a growing student body, budgetary restraints from declining funding, and salaries fixed by collective bargaining agreement, where non-exempt overtime pay was contributing to a budget shortfall.

The challenge

  • The overtime approval process for non-exempt administrative workers was flawed
  • The organization had experienced instances of extensive fraud in the approval of overtime pay
  • Approval of overtime was only ever permitted to, and performed by, the supervisors
  • But supervisors shared their passwords with their assistants for everything else, and that created the opportunity
  • SAP passwords were the only security mechanism before bioLock

A school principal holds SAP authorizations for a great deal more than overtime: purchase orders, ordering supplies, and much else besides. Their assistant holds none of it. So the working arrangement, here and in most organizations, was simply that the assistant signed in as the principal and did the work on their behalf.

That is the part worth pausing on. Almost every executive assistant knows the password of at least one executive, and often several. bioLock did not try to end the arrangement. It attached the biometrics to the task instead of to the sign-in, so it stopped mattering who was signed in.

Working under the principal’s SAP ID, with bioLock attached to each task

Task in SAPWho bioLock lets through
Signing in as the principalPrincipal or assistant
Raising a purchase orderPrincipal or assistant
Approving overtimeThe principal alone. Everyone else refused

What was implemented

  • Individual biometric user profiles associated with specific SAP tasks in HR and payroll, defining any delegated tasks
  • Biometric re-authentication enforced for every sensitive task
  • Tamper-proof logging and an audit trail for each protected transaction
  • Control of extended authorizations, where a user executed transactions under a supervisor’s profile
  • Identification of transactions executed under delegated authority

The outcome

  • Payroll overtime fraud has been eliminated
  • Payroll budget control has been regained
  • The employees responsible for the fraud were held accountable
  • True segregation of duties in the approval of overtime pay
  • Executives can go on sharing a password where it genuinely helps, because the sensitive tasks no longer depend on it